Little Italy has not been a good place to eat, at least in recent
memory. The encroachment of Chinatown on Italian territory, rising
rents, dying families, and changing immigration patterns set an
expiration date on the neighborhood. As classic restaurants closed up
shop, only the most vulgar and bawdy tourist destinations survived.
Those palaces of forgetfulness prostituted themselves to the lowest
bidders—cheap spaghetti in canned red sauce? Louche lasagna, too sweet
with cottage cheese? Floozy pasta e fagioli? All for sale on Mulberry
Street. Although many tourist traps maintained a pretense of earnestness
until the end of red sauce seemed inevitable, the best restaurants, the
dim leather salons and family kitchens where regular customers kept the
food honest, disappeared long before the neighborhood’s current
decline. Today, however, hipster aesthetics have inflected mainstream
consumer preferences. It’s hip to be square. So red sauce is back, baby,
in all its kitschy glory. For be not mistaken, hipster isn’t campy. The
aestheticization of lower middle class custom and culture does not
transform life into style. Ordinary experience fails to and perhaps
cannot achieve transcendental aesthetic value. Instead, the supposed
disclosure of aesthetic value in ordinariness is a patronizing power
play, an attempt to appropriate, rehearse, and eventually perform class
difference as social fetish. Hipster red sauce cooking, alias Torrisi
Italian Specialties, is the latest incarnation of an old school
bourgeois impulse: “slumming it.” Continue reading →